People Executed in the Papal States

This is a list of individuals executed in the Papal States under the authority of the Popes, as well as during the period of French rule between 1810 and 1819. Although capital punishment remained legal in Vatican City from 1929 until 1969, no executions were carried out during that time.

The list does not include individuals executed by other authorities of the Roman Catholic Church, those condemned by Inquisitions outside of the Roman Inquisition, those killed in wars involving the Papal States, or people who were killed extrajudicially.

Most executions were carried out for civil crimes committed within the Papal States, with the condemned tried and convicted in the state’s civil courts. For example, in 1585, Pope Sixtus V launched a strict campaign against crime that became legendary for its severity. According to popular accounts, the crackdown resulted in so many executions that more severed heads were said to have been displayed on the bridge of Castel Sant’Angelo than melons in the Roman markets.

The most detailed records come from the tenure of Giovanni Battista Bugatti, who served as the official executioner of the Papal States from March 22, 1796, to August 17, 1861. Bugatti carefully documented each execution he carried out, recording the name of the condemned, the crime committed, and the place of execution. In total, he recorded 516 executions, which he referred to as “justices,” performed under both papal and French administrations. Bugatti ended his record with the words: “So ends the long list of Bugatti. May that of his successor be shorter.”

Before 1816, the most common methods of execution in the Papal States were beheading with an axe and hanging, while burning at the stake was occasionally used in particularly high-profile cases. After 1816, the guillotine, which had been introduced by the French during their control of Rome, became the standard method.

However, two older methods continued to be used for crimes considered especially horrific. One was the mazzatello, in which the condemned person’s skull was crushed with a large mallet before the throat was cut. Another was drawing and quartering, sometimes performed after hanging.

Executions typically took place at several public locations in Rome. The most common sites included Ponte Sant’Angelo, the bridge leading to Castel Sant’Angelo, Piazza del Popolo, and Via dei Cerchi near the Piazza della Bocca della Verità.

Under papal law, the executioner was officially paid only three cents of the Roman lira per execution, a symbolic payment intended to emphasize the degrading nature of the work. In practice, however, the executioner was also granted other benefits, including free lodging, tax privileges, and a generous pension, such as those awarded to Giovanni Battista Bugatti.